So I somehow made it to the second round in the 18-team league I'm in while having to deal with Oakland and Chicago's QB's for most of the season.

And now, I have a decision to make. I revamped my QB situation via waivers to actually get a little stability there, and now have Sage Rosenfels, Trent Edwards, and the recently-acquired Chris Redman. I only picked up Redman because he's going up against the 27th-ranked pass defense this week (Arizona) while my pickup of Rosenfels from last week faces the #1 ranked pass defense in Indy, and Edwards faces the Giants (11th pass defense in the NFL).

So overall, no good choices. Who do I go with? And suicide is not an option here.

BTW, available on waivers: Kyle Boller (@ Seattle), Tarvaris Jackson (vs. Washington), Josh McCown (@ Jacksonville), AJ Feeley (@ New Orleans, but backup to McNabb), Shaun Hill (vs. Tampa Bay), and Kyle Orton (vs. Green Bay)

Edwards.

Yeah, Edwards.

My instincts (and another person I asked) said Redman. You guys and two others said Edwards.

I went with Edwards.

You all suck. :P

Even worse, the guy I'm playing was going to start Brodie Croyle. At the last minute he put Peyton Manning back in.

See thats why you should have asked me, lol.

Well Edwards was doomed the moment they had snow in Buffalo. They weren't going to do much via the air because of the snow. I'm not even sure I know who the heck Rosenfels is (Sounds like that NFL agent to me). Edwards was the most talented of the 3 you mentioned, but snow negated that.

In standard scoring, 2 TD's and 3 INT's with 200 yards brings in 10 points. That's not great, but considering what you were relying on for QB's, that's not terrible.

Rosenfels was a guy who did nothing in Miami until his final year where he led the Dolphins to two fourth quarter comebacks and outplayed the stiff, Gus Ferotte. Yet for some reason, they decide to not re-sign him for the bear minimum and put all their eggs in one basket with Daunte Culpepper. Rosenfels was due for a breakout and he did that and then he signed with Houston last year, played second fiddle to the even worse, David Carr. So now Matt Schaub is not doing so great and Rosenfels is finally showing that potential to be a first string QB that I thought he had way back in 2004-2005.